Police Interview- Should You Take Part In One?
Author: Justin Craven, Brisbane Criminal Lawyer
You may think by taking part in an interview with police you can tell the police your side of the story and the “truth”. A criminal case is not about what happened (“the truth”) it is about what the prosecution can prove happened. Before you say something to anyone, wouldn’t you want to know what the prosecution can prove?
Is there any benefit to you in participating in an interview with police?
The law says when the Court sentences a person for a criminal offence, it must have regard to how much help the person gave to police in investigating the offence or other offences. So, if you participate in an interview with police and tell them things in relation to the offence, the Court has to have regard to it.
Do you need to participate in an interview with police?
No. In Queensland you do not have to take part in an interview with police, no matter what anyone tells you. Remember, you can exercise your legal right to silence. The law says if police ask you questions about an indictable offence you DO NOT have to say anything.
If I do not participate in an interview with police can this be used against me?
You have nothing to lose by refusing to take part in an interview. In Queensland, a refusal to take part in an interview with police cannot be used against you in Court at trial. This means at trial the prosecution cannot mention anything in relation to you refusing to take part in an interview. However, if you take part in an interview with police, there are many risks for you.
What are the risks of participating in an interview with police?
If you take part in an interview with police, there are several risks for you. These risks can detrimentally affect your case and potentially what a lawyer can do for you.
1. Any admissions made by you against your own interest can be used by the prosecution to prove the offence. People can be convicted based on their own admissions and nothing else. Persons who take part in interviews with police only make the job of a police officer easier.
2. You will have no clue what questions you will be asked. This means you will respond to questions on the spot. You do not have time to think about how you will respond to the questions. You will not know how you will respond to the questions you are asked. The police believe you have committed the offence, and this is why they want to ask you questions. The first time you speak to police you are likely to be nervous and anxious. When this happens, people sometimes say things they later regret. The risk with this, is once you say something to police, it is impossible to take it back. If you say something detrimental to your case, the prosecution will use it to your detriment. For example, if you go to trial the prosecution will play your interview to the jury.
3. You will not know if the police has any evidence to prove you committed the offence.
4. Even if the police say they have evidence they say you committed the offence, you have not seen it. For example, police may say there is CCTV footage showing you committed the offence. However, if you watch the CCTV footage, you may not be able identify anyone from it. You may not believe this, but trust us, it happens.
5. You do not know if the police has any witnesses to the offence. Even if they do, you will not know what they say.
6. You do not know if the police has any forensic evidence (e.g. fingerprints, DNA etc.). Even if the police do, it may prove nothing against you, and it could prove someone else was involved.
7. You may give police information they may not already know. The classic situation where this happens is where police locate a person in possession of a dangerous drug. The person then takes part in an interview with police and they tell police about drugs they have sold. Police then charge the person with trafficking in a dangerous drug or supplying a dangerous drug. Had the person not taken part in an interview with police, the police would not have been able to prove more than a simple possession charge.
8. Things you say may be misinterpreted by others (such as a jury) who listen to your interview with police. The danger with this, is you may think you mean one thing, but the police and a jury may interpret it to mean something difference and detrimentally for you.
FREE-IN-DEPTH NO OBLIGATION CASE REVIEW WITH ONE OF OUR CRIMINAL LAWYERS
SPEAK TO THE EXPERT BRISBANE CRIMINAL LAWYERS BEFORE DOING
Copyright © 2022 Craven Lawyers. All Rights Reserved. Individual liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
Level 34 Waterfront Place
1 Eagle Street
Brisbane City QLD 4000
IPSWICH & SPRINGFIELD OFFICE
5/22 Magnolia Drive
Brookwater QLD 4300
GOLD COAST OFFICE
155 Varsity Parade
Varsity Lakes QLD 4227
SUNSHINE COAST OFFICE
8 Pikki Street
Maroochydore QLD 4558
1800 LAW 000
(1800 529 000)
(07) 3054 7390